Samuel Alito
Samuel Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off the Lights' at the Supreme Court, Criticizes Lower-Court Judges
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito warned Thursday night, Nov. 12, that Congress has the power to effectively shut down the nation’s highest court by cutting off its money. The remarks, made at the Federalist Society’s annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner in Washington, D.C., came about a week after Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate in the midterm elections.
“Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities. And there are many, many, many other things that they can do, or at least try to do,” Alito said, according to The Hill.
“So, it is important to preserve the independence of the judiciary,” he added. “If that is eliminated, then the Constitution as adopted in 1789 will no longer be the same.”
NBC News, which quoted the same passage, rendered the first line slightly differently: “Congress can turn off the lights of the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they will not fund their activities.” The meaning is the same in both versions.
What did Samuel Alito say about Congress?
Alito, a nominee of President George W. Bush, spoke in a conversation with conservative author Mollie Hemingway at the black-tie dinner, part of the Federalist Society’s National Lawyers Convention, NBC News reported. He described the judiciary as the “least dangerous” branch of government and said it is “vulnerable to the executive and to Congress because they are more powerful.”
He did not mention the midterm elections or the coming change in power on Capitol Hill, according to The Hill and NBC News. But the timing drew attention. The Hill noted that Democrats have eyed using Congress’ power of the purse as leverage against the court’s conservative majority before.
The “hand grenade” comparison
Alito also argued that a weaker branch can still do damage. “If you think about a hand grenade, a 500-pound bomb and a nuclear weapon,” he said, according to The Hill, “the hand grenade is the least dangerous. But that is not to say that it is not dangerous.” NBC News reported that he likened the court to the hand grenade in that comparison.
Alito’s criticism of lower-court judges
While defending judicial independence, Alito also criticized some federal district judges for orders that block presidential policies while cases are appealed.
“They are dedicated and they are skillful, but they’re not perfect and they make mistakes,” he said, according to The Hill. “And in some instances, I think they have gone far astray in abuse of their powers.”
NBC News reported that Alito tied those orders to the rise of the Supreme Court’s emergency docket over the past 10 or 15 years. In his telling, presidents frustrated by Congress try to do more on their own, opponents rush to court, and litigators pick districts where they expect a favorable ruling.
“In some instances,” he said, judges have issued “very sweeping and unjustified orders, stopping what the president wants during the pendency of appeal,” according to NBC News. If the district judge turns out to be wrong after years of appeals, he said, “the president, whoever it is, will have been prevented for most of a four-year term from implementing” the initiative.
NBC News noted that the Trump administration has had a very high success rate on the emergency docket, winning interim rulings that let it move ahead on immigration enforcement, the restructuring of the federal government and construction of a White House ballroom while lawsuits continue.
Why it matters
Congress controls the federal budget, including the judiciary’s, and Democrats won majorities in both chambers in this month’s midterms. HuffPost and The Hill both framed Alito’s remarks against that backdrop. The Hill also noted that two of Alito’s colleagues, Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett, made a rare visit to Capitol Hill over the summer to push for a bigger judiciary budget and more security funding as threats against judges rose.
None of the reports reviewed here said that any lawmaker has formally proposed cutting the Supreme Court’s funding. Alito described what Congress could do, not a specific plan.
How many people heard the speech?
Reports differ on the size of the crowd. The Hill said Alito spoke to more than 1,000 conservative lawyers, while NBC News described an audience of more than 2,500 conservative elected officials, lawyers, judges and advocates.
FAQ
Where did Samuel Alito speak?
At the Federalist Society’s Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner in Washington, D.C., on Thursday night, Nov. 12, during the group’s annual convention.
Did Alito mention the midterm elections?
No. According to The Hill and NBC News, he did not refer to the elections or the change in control of Congress.
Is Alito retiring?
The reports reviewed here on his Thursday remarks did not address retirement.
Earlier coverage: Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off the Lights' at the Supreme Court by Cutting Its Funding (Nov 13)
Sources
- Alito says Supreme Court is caught between the president and a Congress that can 'turn off the lights' — NBC News
- Justice Samuel Alito warns Congress could 'turn off the lights' on Supreme Court — The Hill
- Samuel Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off The Lights' At Supreme Court Days After Democrats Win Control — HuffPost