J.J. McCarthy

J.J. McCarthy Returns From Hip Injury as Giants Beat Eagles 19-11 to Extend NFC East Lead

Illustration of an empty football sideline with a medical tent and a lone football on the grass under stadium lights, no people, logos or text
Illustration (AI-generated)

Final: Giants 19, Eagles 11. New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy gave his team a scare on Sunday, Nov. 8, leaving the game in Philadelphia with a hip injury after a hard hit from Eagles linebacker Zack Baun. He returned before the end of the third quarter, and the Giants held on for a 19-11 win, their first victory in Philadelphia since 2013, according to the team.

The win lifted the Giants to 5-2-1 in John Harbaugh’s first season as head coach and stretched their lead in the NFC East. The Eagles fell to 2-7 with their seventh straight loss.

What happened to J.J. McCarthy?

With 12:02 left in the third quarter, McCarthy kept the ball on a designed run, gained three yards and took a hard hit from Baun at the end of the play, the Giants said. Reports described the contact differently: USA Today said he was hit in the midsection, CBS Sports said lower abdomen and side, and Yahoo Sports said the right shoulder. The team listed the injury as a hip injury.

McCarthy got to the sideline on his own and went into the medical tent. When he tried to throw on the sideline, he grabbed his right side and went down in obvious pain, according to USA Today and CBS Sports. He then went to the locker room, and the Giants called him questionable to return.

Baun was also hurt on the play. The Giants listed him with a back injury.

Did J.J. McCarthy play the rest of the game?

Yes. McCarthy came back to celebrate on the sideline after the Giants’ touchdown and re-entered with 17 seconds left in the third quarter, Yahoo Sports reported. He led a drive that ended in a field goal for a 19-8 lead.

He finished 12-of-19 passing for 127 yards and ran four times for 22 yards, per the Giants. He was sacked five times, according to the Giants. Before the injury he was 9-of-13 for 101 yards.

No update on his status for the next game had been reported as of Sunday evening. The Giants host the Washington Commanders on Thursday night, a short turnaround.

Jameis Winston’s relief drive

With McCarthy out, Jameis Winston went 6-of-8 for 71 yards and led the Giants’ only touchdown, a 5-yard pass to tight end Isaiah Likely that put New York ahead 13-8 late in the third quarter. A 27-yard completion to Darnell Mooney set it up.

Winston started four games earlier this season after Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 2, going 2-1-1, according to USA Today. The Giants traded for McCarthy, and he took over as the starter in Week 7. Sunday was his second start with New York.

How the Giants won

The Giants’ defense did most of the work against Joe Milton III, who was making his first career start for Philadelphia:

  • Seven sacks, a season high, including three by rookie Arvell Reese, who also had 12 tackles and a forced fumble.
  • Philadelphia went 5-of-18 on third down.
  • Milton finished 18-of-34 for 169 yards and also led the Eagles with 64 rushing yards.
  • Kicker Dominic Zvada made all four field goals, from 53, 46, 38 and 49 yards.

Saquon Barkley scored Philadelphia’s only touchdown on a 3-yard run in the first quarter.

Giants standings picture

At 5-2-1, the Giants remain first in the NFC East. Dallas also won Sunday, beating Indianapolis on a late Javonte Williams touchdown, Yahoo Sports noted. Thursday’s game against Washington (2-5-1) is a rematch of a 27-27 tie in Week 5.

FAQ

Is J.J. McCarthy hurt?

He suffered a hip injury in the third quarter but returned to finish the game. His status going forward had not been announced Sunday.

Who hit J.J. McCarthy?

Eagles linebacker Zack Baun, who also left with a back injury.

Who won Giants vs. Eagles?

The Giants, 19-11.

Sources