Miami vs. Notre Dame
Notre Dame Knocks Off No. 1 Miami 31-24 as CJ Carr Throws 3 TDs and Luke Talich Breaks Up a Late Fourth-Down Pass
Notre Dame Stadium got another win over a No. 1 team. The Fighting Irish beat top-ranked Miami 31-24 on Saturday night, Nov. 7. CJ Carr threw for 319 yards and three touchdowns, and the defense made a fourth-down stop in the final minutes that Miami’s coach is still angry about.
Final: Notre Dame 31, Miami 24. Both teams are 8-1. The school said it was the program’s 10th win over the nation’s top-ranked team. Notre Dame’s ranking depends on the poll: the school called it the fourth-ranked team, while Sporting News, using the College Football Playoff rankings, had it at No. 11.
How the game played out
The Irish controlled most of the first half. Spencer Porath hit a 44-yard field goal on the opening drive. Carr found Jordan Faison for a 27-yard touchdown with a toe-tap catch in the corner, according to Notre Dame’s recap.
Miami’s first real drive got to the 1-yard line, helped by two defensive holding calls, but the Irish made a goal-line stand. Boubacar Traore and Jaiden Ausberry stopped quarterback Darian Mensah on third down, and Miami settled for a field goal. Carr then went 6 of 7 for 79 yards in a two-minute drill and hit Micah Gilbert for an 18-yard touchdown. Notre Dame led 17-3 at halftime. Sporting News reported Mensah was 6 of 12 for 45 yards in the first half.
Faison’s 56-yard punt return early in the third quarter set up another Carr-to-Gilbert touchdown, this one from 20 yards. That made it 24-3.
Then Miami came back. Mensah threw touchdown passes to Elija Lofton (12 yards) and Cooper Barkate on back-to-back drives to cut the lead to 24-17. Sporting News noted that Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore was out for both scores with a head injury. He returned later.
The drive that decided it
Luke Talich intercepted Mensah to stop the run. Then, facing fourth-and-short at the Miami 43 as the fourth quarter began, Carr found running back Nolan James Jr. on a swing pass for 36 yards. A face-mask penalty moved the ball to the 1, and James scored to make it 31-17.
Miami answered with a 1-yard touchdown from Mensah to Barkate with 9:53 left. Porath then missed a 53-yard field goal, giving the Hurricanes one more chance.
The fourth-down call
Miami drove to the Notre Dame 18. On fourth down, Mensah threw to Lofton in the end zone. Sporting News reported that Lofton came down inbounds but didn’t complete the catch going out of bounds, and Talich was credited with the breakup. Notre Dame then ran out most of the clock behind James. Miami’s hook-and-lateral try on the last play fell apart.
Miami coach Mario Cristobal didn’t hide how he felt about the call. “I’m really, really disappointed that they negated Elija Lofton’s touchdown with two hands on the ball and two feet inbounds,” he said, according to CaneSport’s transcript. He also used profanity to describe it. Later he said, “I don’t need to be criticizing officials,” and gave Notre Dame credit for the win.
Talich described the play simply: “We’re just taught to go through the hands and finish the play, and so that’s what I did,” he said, per Sporting News.
Key numbers
| Notre Dame | Miami | |
|---|---|---|
| QB | CJ Carr: 29-40, 319 yds, 3 TD | Darian Mensah: 22-40, 285 yds, 3 TD, 1 INT |
| Top receiver | Micah Gilbert: 9 catches, 98 yds, 2 TD | Cooper Barkate: 2 TD |
| Record | 8-1 | 8-1 |
Figures are from Notre Dame Athletics and Sporting News.
“Catholics vs. Convicts” echoes
The game paid tribute to former coach Lou Holtz, who died March 4, Sporting News reported. Twenty-two members of the Holtz family attended. Holtz’s 1988 team beat No. 1 Miami 31-30 in the famous “Catholics vs. Convicts” game on the way to Notre Dame’s last national title. Coach Marcus Freeman said he showed his team video of that game this week.
“This is big. This is special,” Freeman said. “I’m not going to sit here and say this is like the other ones. No, this is different.”
Carr also wanted to celebrate. “Dude, let me go celebrate this sucker. We earned this thing,” he said he told staff who tried to steer him toward interviews.
What it means for the playoff
Sporting News wrote that the win secures Notre Dame’s standing in the playoff race. Miami played without star receiver Malachi Toney, who hurt his ankle on Wednesday. Cristobal said losing him that late in the week made it hard to adjust. The Hurricanes now head into the end of the ACC race with questions about the offense without him.
Freeman downplayed the rankings: “It doesn’t matter where you’re ranked until the last week.”
FAQ
Who won Miami vs. Notre Dame?
Notre Dame won 31-24 on Saturday, Nov. 7, in South Bend.
What was the controversial call at the end?
On a fourth-down throw late in the game, Elija Lofton’s catch in the end zone was ruled incomplete. Mario Cristobal said Lofton had two hands on the ball and two feet down.
How did CJ Carr play?
He went 29 of 40 for 319 yards and three touchdowns with no interceptions.
Earlier coverage: Miami vs. Notre Dame Preview: Unbeaten No. 1 Hurricanes Visit South Bend Without Malachi Toney (Nov 7)
Related topics
Sources
- Irish Outlast Hurricanes 31-24 To Take Down #1 — Notre Dame Athletics
- ND stands for No Doubt, at least for one night, as Irish beat No. 1 Miami behind CJ Carr's big night — Sporting News
- Miami Hurricanes' Mario Cristobal, players postgame — On3 (CaneSport)