Jonathan Taylor
Did Jonathan Taylor Get Traded? No: The Colts Kept Their Star RB Despite Second-Round Offers
Jonathan Taylor is staying in Indianapolis. After weeks of speculation, the Colts did not trade their star running back before the NFL’s 4 p.m. ET deadline on Tuesday, Nov. 10, even as they moved two more veterans that same afternoon.
Tom Pelissero reported shortly before the deadline that Indianapolis would not deal Taylor, according to ProFootballTalk and Pro Football Rumors. With the deadline now passed, the Colts cannot make another trade until the offseason, Axios Indianapolis noted.
Did Jonathan Taylor get traded?
No. Multiple teams offered packages that included a second-round pick and more, Pelissero reported, but the Colts “wanted a blockbuster offer to even consider it,” per ProFootballTalk. Axios reported that the team wanted a first-round pick or a blockbuster package.
The Colts also told quarterback Daniel Jones that he would not be traded, according to both ProFootballTalk and Axios.
Who tried to trade for Jonathan Taylor?
Pro Football Rumors reported that the Giants, Vikings, Packers, Broncos, Seahawks and Chiefs all showed varying levels of interest in recent weeks. The Giants appeared to be the most aggressive. After the Colts turned down an offer of a second- and a fifth-round pick, New York pulled its offer, the outlet said.
Pro Football Rumors speculated that Indianapolis may have wanted something closer to what Carolina received for Christian McCaffrey in 2022: second-, third- and fourth-round picks in 2023 plus a fifth-rounder in 2024 from the 49ers. That was the outlet’s speculation, not a reported demand.
Why the Colts kept him
Taylor never asked for a trade, Pro Football Rumors reported. Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon’s preference all along was to keep him, the outlet said, calling him the face of the franchise. Interim general manager Ed Dodds still listened to offers.
Taylor signed a two-year, $44 million extension over the summer and is under contract through 2028, per Pro Football Rumors. He debuted with the Colts as a second-round pick in 2020 and is a three-time Pro Bowler.
Axios noted that Taylor had given what looked like a heartfelt goodbye to fans after Sunday’s loss to Dallas, which now appears to have been premature.
Is Jonathan Taylor getting traded later?
Not this season. But Pro Football Rumors said the Colts could revisit trade talks in the offseason, when a new general manager may decide Taylor’s future. Dodds, who has run the front office since Chris Ballard was fired Oct. 19, could be a candidate for the job, the outlet said, though Irsay-Gordon might hire from outside.
The rest of the Colts’ sell-off
Indianapolis is 2-7 after five straight losses, including Sunday’s 27-23 loss to the Cowboys, in which the Colts led 23-20 late before allowing a touchdown and then throwing an interception on their final drive, according to Axios.
The team has traded four veterans since late October:
| Player | Sent to | Colts received |
|---|---|---|
| G Quenton Nelson | Seahawks | 2027 third, 2028 fifth |
| DT DeForest Buckner | 49ers | 2027 fourth |
| WR Keenan Allen | 49ers | 2027 sixth |
| WR Josh Downs | Chiefs | 2027 fourth and fifth (sent a 2027 seventh) |
Trade terms per Axios Indianapolis. Pro Football Rumors noted that the four traded players were impending free agents who will finish the season with contenders, while Taylor will play out 2026 on a team it expects to miss the playoffs again.
Coach Shane Steichen sounded ready to move on. “It’ll be great to get the trade deadline over,” he said Monday, according to Axios. “Obviously, there’s been a lot of speculation, a lot of talk, a lot of noise the last three weeks.”
What’s next
The Colts host the Miami Dolphins at 1 p.m. Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium, Axios reported. The immediate challenge, the outlet wrote, is competing with a much thinner roster.
Related topics: Did Jonathan Taylor get traded, JT trade, Colts news, NFL trade deadline, ProFootballTalk.
FAQ
Did the Colts trade Jonathan Taylor?
No. He stayed in Indianapolis through the deadline.
What was the best offer for Jonathan Taylor?
Multiple teams offered a second-round pick and more, per reports. The Giants’ second- and fifth-round offer was turned down.
Can the Colts still trade him this season?
No. The deadline has passed.
Sources
- Report: Despite multiple offers, Colts will not trade Jonathan Taylor — NBC Sports / ProFootballTalk
- Colts Will Not Trade Jonathan Taylor Before Deadline — Pro Football Rumors
- Colts trade Downs, keep Taylor in trade deadline scramble — Axios Indianapolis