Ebenezer
'Ebenezer' Reviews: Critics Split on Johnny Depp's Scrooge in Ti West's Spooky 'Christmas Carol' as It Opens
“Ebenezer,” director Ti West’s horror-tinged take on Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol,” opened in theaters this weekend with Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge. The film is being treated as Depp’s return to major studio movies, and the early verdict from critics is mixed at best: praise for the Gothic atmosphere and craft, and sharp disagreement over Depp himself.
What are the Ebenezer reviews saying?
Entertainment Weekly summed up the first wave as leaving critics “cold.” EW reported the film held a 50% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes from about 70 reviews late Thursday, with a 47 out of 100 on Metacritic, and noted that most of the positive-leaning reviews scored it around 6 out of 10. Deadline, writing Friday morning, put the Rotten Tomatoes figure at 53%. Those scores move as more reviews come in, so expect them to keep shifting.
The harshest takes
- IndieWire’s David Ehrlich called Depp’s performance “an advent calendar of empty affectations without a soul to anchor them,” as quoted by EW.
- Consequence’s Liz Shannon Miller wrote that Depp “utterly fails at capturing Ebenezer’s transition towards kindness,” per EW.
- TheWrap’s Amelia Emberwing faulted Nathaniel Halpern’s screenplay, writing that “its attempts at humor are all whiffs,” EW reported.
The middle ground
Several critics liked the movie more than its star. Vulture’s Alison Wilmore called the film “pretty good” overall but said Depp seems to think “he’s starring in a family comedy” while the rest of the movie leans toward horror, according to EW. RogerEbert.com’s Matt Zoller Seitz described it as “skillfully done” but said Depp’s approach is “all wrong for a work of such delicacy.”
The kinder reviews
Variety’s Guy Lodge wrote that Depp “makes for a perfectly solid, by-the-book Scrooge — with occasional moments of ripe inspiration in his line readings.” Lodge also called the film “too frightening for many children and too old hat for many adults.” The Hollywood Reporter’s Frank Scheck, quoted by EW, wrote that the film “fulfills its ostensible goal of restoring the actor to A-list status” and that Depp’s “charisma and star power eventually come through.”
Is Ebenezer a new story or a straight adaptation?
Despite marketing taglines such as “Before he was Scrooge he was Ebenezer,” Variety’s review says the film is “a mostly straightforward take” on Dickens, with “slightly grislier ghost effects” than most versions. It adds a prologue showing how Jacob Marley died, and lightly expands the relationship between young Ebenezer and his former fiancée, Belle.
Variety singled out production designer Eve Stewart as the film’s “clear MVP” for a dank, crooked version of Dickensian London, and highlighted Andrea Riseborough’s unsettling Ghost of Christmas Past.
Who is in the Ebenezer cast?
According to Variety and EW, the cast includes:
- Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge
- Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley
- Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit
- Andrea Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past
- Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present
- Sam Claflin as Scrooge’s nephew Fred
- Daisy Ridley as Fred’s wife, Clara
- Ellie Bamber as Belle and Arthur Conti as young Ebenezer
Is Ebenezer OK for kids?
The film is rated PG-13 and runs 116 minutes, per Variety. Multiple critics flagged that it may be too scary for young children. THR’s Scheck suggested it may be the first version of the story “not really suitable for young children,” and Variety said the same about “many children.” Parents may want to check a detailed content guide before going.
How is Ebenezer doing at the box office?
Deadline reported that “Ebenezer” earned $1.5 million from Thursday previews that began at 2 p.m. The film was hoping for at least $20 million domestically over the weekend, which would likely be enough for No. 1, plus about $20 million from 63 international markets. Deadline put the film’s net budget at $38 million.
Deadline compared the previews with $3.7 million for “Red One” and $2.2 million for “The Grinch” in 2018, while noting that Christmas movies are hard to compare. Audience exit polling was stronger than the critics’ response: Deadline cited 4.5 stars and a 63% definite recommend on PostTrak.
Deadline and EW identify Paramount as the studio behind the film; Variety’s credit block lists a Universal Pictures release, so the distribution details differ between those reports. The weekend totals were not final at the time of writing.
FAQ
When did Ebenezer come out?
It is now playing in theaters, with previews on Thursday, Nov. 12, and its opening weekend Nov. 13 to 15.
Who directed Ebenezer?
Ti West, the filmmaker behind “The House of the Devil” and the “X” trilogy. Nathaniel Halpern wrote the screenplay.
Is Ebenezer a horror movie?
Not exactly. Variety describes it as tinged with horror but stopping short of an outright horror film, keeping Dickens’ redemptive arc.
Sources
- Johnny Depp's comeback leaves critics cold in first Ebenezer reviews — Entertainment Weekly
- 'Ebenezer' Review: Johnny Depp Scowls His Way Through a Spookily Atmospheric but Redundant 'Christmas Carol' Retread — Variety
- 'Ebenezer' Counts $1.5M In Previews On Thursday; Johnny Depp Pic Hopes For $40M WW Opening — Deadline