Madden Movie
'Madden' Reviews: Critics Sack Nicolas Cage's John Madden Biopic on Prime Video
John Madden won a Super Bowl, became one of the most famous voices in sports broadcasting and lent his name to one of the best-selling video game franchises ever. Now he is the subject of a Hollywood biopic, and the early verdict is rough.
“Madden,” directed by David O. Russell and starring Nicolas Cage as the coach-turned-broadcaster, began streaming on Prime Video on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Critics have mostly panned it, though a few found things to enjoy.
What is “Madden” about?
The film follows Madden and his friend and boss, Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis, from their Super Bowl-winning days through Madden’s reinvention as a broadcaster and the creation of the Madden NFL video game, according to Yahoo Entertainment. The movie also tracks his marriage to Virginia Madden, who, in Yahoo’s description, would like him to think about something other than football once in a while.
It was produced by Amazon MGM Studios, according to RogerEbert.com.
“Madden” cast
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| Nicolas Cage | John Madden |
| Christian Bale | Al Davis |
| Kathryn Hahn | Virginia Madden |
| John Mulaney | Trip Hawkins, Electronic Arts founder |
| Sienna Miller | Carol Davis |
| Joel Murray | Pat Summerall |
Per Yahoo Entertainment, RogerEbert.com and the Guardian.
The Guardian noted that Cage was not the first choice: it reported that Will Ferrell passed on the role before Cage took it.
What critics are saying
The reviews lean heavily on football metaphors, and most are negative.
- The Associated Press said the biopic “can’t find a playbook to stick with.” Critic Jake Coyle wrote that the movie keeps switching among a marriage story, a portrait of the Madden-Davis friendship and the tale of a coach figuring out life after the sidelines. He called it “a goofy, unfunny comedy that can’t find the end zone,” but stressed it “isn’t an insincere effort,” adding that its “affection for John Madden… is palpable.”
- RogerEbert.com was harsher, calling it a “drab biopic” with a “threadbare script” and saying Cage “appears disengaged from the flat material,” in makeup, a fat suit and “an unconvincing blonde wig.”
- The Guardian called Cage’s Madden “a thin caricature” and said Russell’s film is closer to the Pop-Tarts movie than Ben Affleck’s Air.
- The A.V. Club, quoted by Yahoo, gave it a D+ and called it “a disastrous doink,” saying Russell “muffs the opening kickoff, blows his ACL, and gets carted off the field.”
There were a few kinder takes. Variety’s Owen Gleiberman, quoted by Yahoo, likened it to “an SNL sketch shot and edited by Scorsese” and gave one of the film’s few positive reviews.
Who stood out?
Several critics singled out the supporting cast. Yahoo reported that reviewers preferred Bale’s turn as Davis, and the AP’s Coyle highlighted Hahn, writing that when the movie briefly comes together, “usually it’s when Hahn is talking.”
RogerEbert.com was unimpressed across the board, saying Bale opts “to chew scenery rather than conjure any believable emotion” and that Mulaney “shows up with nothing to offer.”
Rotten Tomatoes score
Early scores were low. Yahoo reported a 20% score on Rotten Tomatoes based on 20 reviews as of Wednesday afternoon, up from 13% that morning. Scores like these move as more reviews come in, so check the current number.
Why the story drew so much attention
Madden remains one of football’s most recognizable figures. The Guardian noted his coaching win percentage exceeded even Vince Lombardi’s. Generations of fans knew him first as a broadcaster and later through Madden NFL. The film arrives a week before Thanksgiving, a holiday fans long associated with Madden’s broadcasts, and Yahoo noted it even includes a turducken.
The film also puts two less-famous figures in the spotlight: Al Davis, the late Raiders owner played by Bale, and Virginia Madden, John’s wife, played by Hahn.
How to watch “Madden”
“Madden” is streaming now on Prime Video, per Yahoo Entertainment and RogerEbert.com.
FAQ
Is “Madden” on Prime Video?
Yes. It started streaming Wednesday, Nov. 18.
Who plays John Madden?
Nicolas Cage. Christian Bale plays Al Davis and Kathryn Hahn plays Virginia Madden.
Is “Madden” good?
Most critics say no, though a few, including Variety’s Owen Gleiberman, enjoyed it.
Who directed “Madden”?
David O. Russell.
Sources
- 'A disastrous doink': The 'Madden' reviews are in, and critics are having a field day — Yahoo Entertainment
- Movie Review: 'Madden' biopic can't find a playbook to stick with — Associated Press
- Madden review – Nicolas Cage is a cartoonish NFL legend in David O Russell's stinker — The Guardian
- Madden review: Awful Prime Video biopic fumbles in every possible way — RogerEbert.com